4. It's a no from me

I don't see anything happening with this product

Honestly, just couldn't get over this smell. Also might be too strong of VitC for me

Super oily, also felt comedogenic

Not moisturizing, woke up in the morning feeling super dry lips

Horrid white cast, sting eyes, pills

Way too metallic

Rosmarinus Officinalis Leaf Extract breaks me out with deep, cystic pimples the next day, and only in the areas where this is applied

Hate this product. Doesn't remove makeup, ridiculously thick (so hard to dispense), separates, and smells bad, leaves residue so you need a second cleanse anyway. 1000% don't recommend

Rosmarinus Officinalis Leaf Extract breaks me out badly. With the balm, all around the lip line

Rosmarinus Officinalis Leaf Extract breaks me out, I only use it on the body now.

Globby and applied uneven-- I think mine might have separated in storage.

Salicylic acid tends to kill my skin barrier, especially leave on products

Discovered that this is what is destroying my skin barrier. Much too strong for me.

Pretty sure something in this is disrupting my skin barrier, which is not ideal since I use this when my skin needs help. Used it up on body. Not bad if you're not sensitive

Much too thick and too much effort to squeeze out. Especially when cold